Fresh vs. Faux Holiday Wreaths: Which Should You Order?
A holiday wreath on the front door is one of the simplest, most welcoming ways to celebrate the season. It greets guests, sets the festive mood and makes coming home feel special.
But when it's time to choose, there's a question: fresh or faux?
Both have their place, and both can look stunning. Here's an honest comparison to help you decide quickly.
At a glance
Fresh wreaths are made from real evergreen branches, berries, pinecones and seasonal botanicals.
Faux wreaths are made from artificial greenery and decorations, designed to be reused year after year.
Scent
Fresh: nothing compares to the natural fragrance of fresh fir, pine, cedar and eucalyptus. A fresh wreath fills your entryway with the smell of the holidays every time you open the door.
Faux: no natural scent. Some people add scented ornaments or sprays, but it's not quite the same.
Winner: fresh, by a mile.
Look and front-door impact
Fresh: real greenery has natural texture, depth and variation that feels lush and organic. Fresh berries, pinecones and seasonal accents add authentic beauty. Up close, there's simply no substitute.
Faux: high-quality faux wreaths can look very realistic from a distance, and they keep a perfect, consistent shape. Lower-quality versions can look flat or plastic up close.
Winner: fresh for natural beauty; high-quality faux for consistency.
Longevity
Fresh: a fresh wreath typically lasts about three to five weeks outdoors in cool weather, sometimes longer. Indoors, in a warm, dry home, it may dry out in one to two weeks.
Faux: can last for many years with proper storage.
Winner: faux, clearly.
Weather
This is where your location and your door really matter.
Fresh wreaths do best:
- On shaded, north- or east-facing doors
- In cool temperatures
- Protected from direct afternoon sun
- Away from heat sources, including warm air from inside the house
Fresh wreaths struggle:
- In direct sun, especially on west- or south-facing doors
- During warm spells, which Southern California often has in December
- Between a front door and a glass storm door, where heat builds up
- In very dry, windy conditions, like Santa Ana winds
Faux wreaths handle sun, heat and wind without drying out, though intense sun can fade colors over time.
Winner: faux, for harsh or unpredictable weather.
Price
Fresh: you buy a new one each year. Premium designer fresh wreaths with luxurious botanicals cost more, but they deliver a truly special look.
Faux: a higher upfront cost for a quality wreath, but you can reuse it for many seasons, spreading the cost out over time.
Winner: faux, over many years; fresh is a seasonal investment in beauty.
Sustainability
Fresh: made from natural, biodegradable materials. At the end of the season, many components can be composted.
Faux: made from plastics and wire, but reused for years, which reduces the need to buy new.
Winner: it depends. A fresh wreath composts; a faux wreath used for many years avoids yearly purchases.
When faux is the smarter choice
- You decorate early and keep your wreath up from mid-November through January
- Your door gets strong direct sun or is exposed to heat
- You live in a very warm or windy area
- You're hanging it indoors, near a fireplace or heater
- You want a low-maintenance, reusable option
When fresh feels special
- You love the scent of real evergreens
- You want a luxurious, natural look for hosting and holiday photos
- Your door is shaded and stays cool
- You enjoy seasonal traditions, like choosing a new wreath each year
- It's a gift: a fresh designer wreath feels thoughtful and generous
How to make a fresh wreath last longer
- Hang it in the shade, out of direct sun
- Mist it with water every few days, especially during warm or dry weather
- Keep it away from heat sources like vents and fireplaces
- Avoid hanging it between a door and a glass storm door
- If it's indoors, keep it in the coolest room possible
Our holiday wreaths
Our Christmas collection includes wreath designs like the Luxury Christmas Evergreen Wreath and Christmas Wreath – Pink Frost, alongside winter greens, amaryllis and ilex berries. You'll also find holiday pieces among our premium bouquets.
Have questions about materials, sizing or which wreath suits your door? Contact us. We're happy to help you choose, and to reserve your wreath before the December rush.
For custom holiday décor, from wreaths to full entryway displays, explore our floral design services.
The bottom line
Choose fresh if you want scent, natural beauty and a special seasonal moment, and your door stays shaded and cool.
Choose faux if you want to decorate for months, your door faces harsh sun or heat, or you'd like a reusable option.
Reserve your wreath early. Holiday wreaths are popular, and December fills up fast. We deliver across Los Angeles and Orange County.